Best Brass Bath Caddy: Finish, Fit and Tub Shape
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Details
People who search for a brass bath caddy usually want a gold or brass look across the tub. The honest picture on Amazon is mixed. Only one of the five products below lists brass as its material. The other four are stainless steel, glass or marble pieces with a gold finish. This guide sorts them out using only listing details.
Quick answer
If you want real brass, the expandable brass tray with a chrome polished finish is the only one that lists it, and note that its finish is chrome, not gold. If you want a gold look, the BVL (with a marble base), the NEWRAIN and the Cabilock all list gold or golden colors in stainless steel. If you need the longest reach across the tub, the other stainless steel expandable tray lists 35.4 inches in length. For related tub storage, see our guides to a bathroom bath caddy, a wooden bath caddy and a corner bath caddy.
Comparison table
| Product | Material | Finish or color | Listed size | Weight | Extras |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| BVL tray with marble base | Marble, stainless steel | Gold | 21.9 x 7.17 x 2.83 inches (L x W x H) | 2.9 kg | Non slip, integrated tablet holder |
| Stainless steel expandable tray | Stainless steel | Gold | 35.4 x 6.7 x 2 inches (L x W x H) | 1.34 kg | Adjustable, expandable |
| Brass expandable tray | Brass | Chrome polished | 7.8 deep x 25.6 wide x 3.58 high inches | 1.5 kg | Free standing, expandable |
| NEWRAIN tray | Not stated (title says 304 stainless steel) | Gold | Not stated | Not stated | Rustproof, tablet holder included |
| Cabilock tray | Glass, stainless steel | Golden | 24.8 x 7.87 x 1.57 inches (L x W x H) | 2.2 pounds | Handle, lightweight, rust resistant |
The five trays
BVL Stainless Steel Bathtub Tray with Marble Base
A gold stainless steel tray with a white marble base. It measures 21.9 by 7.17 by 2.83 inches and weighs 2.9 kg, the heaviest here. The listing names non slip and an integrated tablet holder. It is stainless steel and marble, not brass.
Suits: anyone who wants a gold look and a place to rest a tablet.
- Pros: non slip, tablet holder, marble base.
- Cons: heavy at 2.9 kg; it is not an expandable design, as far as the listing states.
Skip if: you want solid brass.
See the BVL tray on Amazon (affiliate link)
Stainless Steel Expandable Bathtub Caddy Tray (Gold)
A gold stainless steel tray that is adjustable and expandable. It is listed at 35.4 inches long, 6.7 inches wide and 2 inches high, and 1.34 kg, which is the longest of the fully specified trays and lighter than the BVL and the brass tray. It is stainless steel, not brass.
Suits: wider tubs where a fixed tray would not reach.
- Pros: expandable, adjustable, light.
- Cons: the listing gives no tablet holder or rim grip details in the facts shown.
Skip if: you want brass or a marble look.
See the expandable stainless tray on Amazon (affiliate link)
Brass Expandable Bathtub Caddy with Chrome Polished Finish
The only listing here that names brass as the material. It is free standing and expandable, 7.8 inches deep, 25.6 inches wide and 3.58 inches high, weighing 1.5 kg. The finish is chrome polished, so it will look silver, not gold.
Suits: buyers who want brass construction rather than a gold coating.
- Pros: brass listed as the material, expandable.
- Cons: chrome finish; no tablet holder is named.
Skip if: you specifically want a gold color.
See the brass tray on Amazon (affiliate link)
NEWRAIN Gold Bathtub Tray Caddy
A gold tray in a modern style. The title says rustproof 304 stainless steel and expandable width, and the listing names a tablet holder as an included component. Dimensions, weight and a material field are not stated in the facts available.
Suits: someone who wants a gold tray with a tablet holder and is happy to check size on the product page.
- Pros: gold finish, rustproof claim, tablet holder.
- Cons: no size or weight stated here.
Skip if: you need to compare exact dimensions before buying.
See the NEWRAIN tray on Amazon (affiliate link)
Cabilock Luxury Stainless Steel Bathtub Tray
A golden tray with glass and stainless steel, 24.8 inches in the title and 24.8 by 7.87 by 1.57 inches in the details. It weighs 2.2 pounds. The listing names a handle and says durable, lightweight and rust resistant.
Suits: a shallow tray with a handle and a glass element.
- Pros: handle, lightweight and rust resistant claims.
- Cons: only 1.57 inches high, so it is shallow.
Skip if: you want to hold tall bottles.
See the Cabilock tray on Amazon (affiliate link)
Buying checklist
- Decide whether you want real brass or only a gold look. Read the material field, not just the color.
- Measure the width of your tub rim and compare it with the listed length or width.
- If you want a tablet holder, check that the listing names one.
- Check weight if you plan to lift the tray often.
- Look at the finish: gold, golden and chrome polished are different looks.
- Check that the tray will not block a tap, grab bar or shower door track.
FAQ
Which of these trays is actually brass?
Only the expandable tray with a chrome polished finish lists brass as its material. The others list stainless steel, with marble or glass on two of them, and gold colors.
Which tray reaches the farthest across the tub?
The stainless steel expandable tray is listed at 35.4 inches long. The brass tray is listed at 25.6 inches wide, the Cabilock at 24.8 inches and the BVL at 21.9 inches.
Which trays have a tablet holder?
The BVL names an integrated tablet holder and the NEWRAIN lists a tablet holder as an included component. The other listings do not mention one in the details shown.
How heavy are these trays?
The BVL is listed at 2.9 kg, the brass tray at 1.5 kg, the stainless steel expandable tray at 1.34 kg and the Cabilock at 2.2 pounds. The NEWRAIN weight is not stated.
Does a gold finish mean solid brass?
No. A color or finish name tells you how the tray looks, not what it is made of. Check the material field on each listing.
Closing note
If brass matters to you, the one tray that lists it has a chrome finish. If the look matters most, four of the five trays here are gold or golden. Check the full product pages for sizes and details this review marks as not stated.
